Central Ohio’s Favorite

Makers Market

Not Your Mama’s Craft Market is a one-of-a-kind craft market with a loyal and enthusiastic base of shoppers.  For the past 13+ years, many of our shoppers have done all of their gift shopping at our markets.

We accept only the best of the best midwest makers offering the finest-quality, trendy, and unique handmade goods.  That passion for the creative community has made us one of the top 10 events in Columbus for the past several years.

Want to join our growing and passionate community?  Apply to our next market now!

The Warehouse District Farm & Flea

Sundays, May 19 – Sept 29, 2024
The Kee
Downtown Columbus

* Rolling Applications Open (vendors chosen one month before each market date) 

Peachy Palooza Featuring The Peach Truck

Saturday, July 20, 2024
Inside The Kee
Downtown Columbus

* Applications close June 16th

Fall Festival Market

Sunday, Oct 13, 2024
BrewDog Taproom & Brewery
Canal Winchester

* Applications close August 22nd

Downtown Columbus Holiday Market

Sunday, Nov 17, 2024
The Kee
Downtown Columbus

* Applications close September 1st

Dublin Holiday Market

Sunday, Nov 24, 2024
The Exchange at Bridge Park

* Applications closr September 1st

Village Lights Market

Sunday, Dec 8, 2024
Schiller Community Rec Ctr
German Village

* Applications close September 1st 


Santa Brunch Market

Sunday, Dec 15, 2024
BrewDog Taproom & Brewery
Canal Winchester

* Applications close September 1st


How can I apply to be a maker?

Applications open approximately three months before a market.  Sign up for our mailing list to be notified when applications open.

What is Not You Mama's Craft Market's COVID-19 policy?

NYMCM and its partnering venues will be following all current social-distance safe-practice guidelines from the CDC and Ohio Department of Health with regards to COVID-19 at all of its markets.  These health and safety policies are subject to change as the CDC and Ohio Department of Health make changes to their respective guidelines.

What criteria and qualifications do you look for in your applicants?

Our market is juried by select members of our staff and other individuals in the local makers scene, whose opinions and tastes we value and trust.  Together we review the pool of applications handpick the artists and makers that are the best fit for NYMCM. We thoughtfully and carefully choose applicants based on a number of criteria, listed below.  You can also check out our Instagram page to see what makers we have chosen in the past.

    • Your work is designed and made by hand. Please provide information in your application if your products aren’t entirely made by you or by hand.
    • Your work overall is cohesive and consistent, and you provide clear examples for us to view.
    • Your work is unique. If you are a returning vendor, we want to see how your work has progressed since last participating. We always want to offer our customers fresh ideas and items.
    • The average price of your items typically ranges between $1-150 and reflect a good value/price ratio.  Typically, you know what your work is worth!
    • Your website and/or social media pages provide clean and clear photos that are cohesive with the quality of NYMCM and can be easily shared for media purposes.
    • You demonstrate that you are good at following directions and reading provided information.
    • If you are a pre-packaged edibles vendor, you offer unique packaging and flavors and have a well-designed booth. We expect artisanal food vendors to live up to the same level of integrity and quality with their products and displays as our other handmade participants.
How does the maker and vendor selection jury work?

The NYMCM jury consists of 5 members, each of whom is active in handmade small business. After the application period closes, application fee payments are confirmed. If the fee has not been paid by the due date, the application is considered incomplete and discarded. All paid applications are then sorted by genre and individually scored according to the criteria outlined below. The top scorers are compared within their genre and selected to join the markert. A number of vendors in each category are offered a spot on our waitlist as cancellations often happen for personal reasons.

How much are your vendor fees?

Each market has a slightly different vendor fee structure.  Vendor fees will be listed in the application.

What does the vendor fee include?

Your fee covers venue costs, digital and print advertising, promotional materials including posters and other costs required to organize a Market. Makers will also be featured and tagged on our social media pages and website leading up to and during the market.

Are tables and chairs provided for makers and vendors? Is there anything else I need to bring?

Tables and chairs are not provided. Upon acceptance, vendors may be required to provide a barrier between neighboring vendor spaces.  Barriers may be as simple as a clear vinyl shower curtain or a canvas/fabric backdrop. In addition, all vendors must supply a hand sanitizer in their space for customer use.

I was a NYMCM maker in the past. Does that mean I'm guaranteed a spot at the next market?

No. What makes NYMCM such a unique market is our desire to bring our customers the newest and most current trends in handmade every year. We also want to showcase the best that the Columbus, Ohio maker community has to offer.

To do this we need a vast variety of makers at each market, along with new merchandise. This is why we hold such a rigorous application process. We LOVE having return vendors, but they must undergo the same jury process as everyone else. We check to see what new products they are offering and also discuss what kind of maker they were in the past. Did they help share market info online? Were they easy to work with? Did they follow all of our rules and deadlines? 

I applied in the past and was not accepted. Should I even try applying again?

Heck yes! As stated in the previous answer, we are always looking for new Makers. We have to turn down so many fantastic Makers simply due to space constraints at each market. This year there are twice the opportunities for Makers to be selected! Keep growing your skills and keep applying! We’d love to have you at one of our markets!

What if my business doesn't have a web page or social media accounts?

As much as we love to accommodate all makers, we highly depend on digital exposure for the all-around success of our markets. We do not require an expensive website or thousands of posts or followers from our makers, but we do require some sort of internet presence. This makes promoting, collecting promotion material, and communication much easier on our end. A simple Instagram or Facebook account or Etsy page is perfect! If you do not have an active online page, NYMCM may not be the right fit for you. 

Do you allow direct sales businesses?

No, we do not allow direct sale businesses to be a vendor at Not Your Mama’s Craft Market. No exceptions will be made. If you pay the application fee and apply with a direct sales business, you will not be refunded. 

Can makers share booths?

Booth sharing is accepted on a case by case basis. Please reach out to us by email at notyourmamascraftmarket@gmail.com if you’d like to share a booth space. Both makers must apply and be accepted in order to share a space.

If I'm chosen to be a NYMCM vendor, what is required of me?
  • Watch your inbox! We try not to overload Makers on emails. When we do email you it is usually full of lots of important information. Please take the time to read these emails and file them to refer to later. It is very time consuming for us to respond to questions already addressed. 
  • Carefully read and make a plan to put our safety policies and procedures in place. 
  • Prepare your booth space. We are known for showcasing Makers with the most outstanding booth displays. Don’t get lost in the crowd by not preparing the look of your display early. Presentation is just as important as your products. We highly suggest making a tape outline of your booth dimensions on the floor and doing a mock up of your space. Remember YOU have to fit in the space too!  No extra room outside of your booth is available for your display. All vendors must bring their own table and chairs. A floor-length table covering is required for all tables. Check out our Pinterest Board for ideas. 
  • Due to state mandated COVID-19 guidelines, vendors may be required to provide a barrier between neighboring vendor spaces. Barriers may be as simple as a clear vinyl shower curtain or a canvas/fabric backdrop. Vendors must supply a hand sanitizer inside their vendor space for customer use.
  • Vendors will be given digital marketing tools for social media use. We require vendors to share these marketing materials across their social media accounts.
How do I prepare to be a maker or vendor at NYMCM?

FIRST, read over our COVID-19 Safety Policy.

Do your research! There are many great books, blogs and networks out there to help you move forward with your business. We would love to help each maker personally figure out how much product to make, how to set up their space, and how to price their items. Though, with over 100 makers and the 100s of hours we dedicate to putting on a market, unfortunately we cannot. We can, however, direct you to our Pinterest Page that has many resources for makers. 

I’ve been accepted, but I forgot which booth size I applied for. Where can I find that information?

The easiest way to find your booth size is to refer to your acceptance email or PayPal invoice. You are also welcome to contact us, and we will respond as soon as we are able.

I haven't done many markets. How do I prepare?

Do your research! There are many great books, blogs and networks out there to help you move forward with your business. We would love to help each Maker personally figure out how much product to make, how to set up their space, and how to price their items but with over 100 Makers and 100s of hours it takes to put on a market, unfortunately we cannot. We can, however, direct you to our Pinterest Page that has many resources for Makers.

What if I was selected and can no longer make the market?

Contact us as soon as possible. You may refer to the market agreement that is attached to your Acceptance email for our cancellation policy.

Do you have a question that isn’t answered above? Reach out and we’ll do our best to answer it!

Not Your Mama’s Craft Market 2024 Market Schedule

July 20, 2024

Yo, we’ve got THE PEACH TRUCK straight from Nashville!  If the idea of fresh peaches, live music and bushels of people excites you, then it doesn’t get sweeter than this. Not Your Mama’s Craft Market, The Kee and The Peach Truck are getting ready to jam for their brand new Peachy Palooza!   We’ve been partnering with some of Columbus’ favorite chefs, bakers and mixologists on some juicy culinary one-of-a-kind peach-perfect creations. This local shopping dreamland will feature over 80 local creatives, curated boutiques and vintage booths plus the extra special addition of peach food and drink options, live music and our guest of honor, THE PEACH TRUCK. Stick around The Kee after the market clears out because they will be continuing the party late into the night with an evening full of more music, more drinks, more food!  They even have galleries and game rooms!  

Sundays, May 19 - Sept 29, 2024

NEW MARKET, WHO DIS?!?! NYMCM is pairing up with The Kee for a weekly Farmer’s Market/Vintage Flea every Sunday, May 19th through September 29th. We are calling it The Warehouse District Farm & Flea! These markets will look a little different than the NYMCM Markets you are used to. Although we will still be hosting handmade vendors, these casual traditional farmers market style markets. Food and produce will be the big event with the addition of a few vintage and handmade vendors. On the first Sunday of every month, we will kick it up a notch by adding additional vintage vendors to the farmers market mix for a shopping extravaganza we are calling our SUPERMARKET SUNDAY! 

November 24, 2024

November 24th is a busy day for NYMCM.

This market will be 1 of 2 happening on Nov. 26th. NYMCM will be back at BrewDog in their 6,000 sq ft craft beer museum.

This market is free to attend and will showcase 50+ creatives!

Again, you can expect quite the variety of handmade goods, perfect for your holiday shopping needs! Enjoy our community feel while also partaking in BrewDog’s extensive drink and food menu.

November 17, 2024

Introducing our newest Holiday Market! The second of two amazing markets happening this day, the Nov. 17th Holiday Market at The Kee will be one for the books! Our shoppers and makers LOVED our summer market at The Kee so much, we had to return for a one of a kind holiday shopping experience. With over 100 of the best small businesses to shop from, you aren’t going to want to leave, and you won’t have to! This new venue can keep you busy from brunch till the wee hours of the night with bars, games, galleries, multiple restaurants and more all located conveniently in Downtown Columbus. Worried about parking? Don’t. There is a huge lot on site.

December 8, 2024

The Dec. 8th NYMCM Village Lights Market returns to German Village. Join us as we pack the Schiller Community Recreation Center with 100+ vendors inside two gymnasiums. Shop the day away with us, then head outside and explore the bustling brick streets of German Village’s famous light festival. Hop on off the free trolley to explore all Village Lights has to offer including live music, local shops and restaurants, visits with Santa, and more!

December 15, 2024

The Dec. 15th Market will be held back at BrewDog’s Canal Winchester location. With 50+ Small Businesses and tons of festive activities happening, this market is a family-friendly favorite. Not Your Mama’s Craft Market will yet again take place during BrewDog’s famous Santa Brunch! Last year this event included Santa, live music and LIVE Reindeer. We can’t wait to see what they have in store for all of us this year!

Join Our Columbus, Ohio Makers Community